New Organic Veg Rules

And there was I, thinking that organic veg was all about being free of pesticides (however silly that worry is). Apparently not:

The Soil Association, which licenses 85 per cent of
Britain’s organic produce, is consulting on a range of policies to
reduce the environmental impact of food being flown to Britain from
thousands of miles away.

Among the proposals under
consideration to cut "food miles" is a ban on air-freighted produce
using the organic label. These vegetables are said to be responsible
for 11 per cent of the carbon emissions produced by British food
transport.

I have a feeling that if the do this they’ll regret it. For once we open up the definition of "organic" to how much CO2 is produced then many domestic producers are going to find themselves decertified. For example, New Zealand lamb, even with the shipping, produces less CO2 than home grown. Spanish field tomatoes less than home grown hothouse ones.

6 responses

  1. AntiCitizenOne Avatar
    AntiCitizenOne

    “Organic” veg (full of organic pesticide) has got too mainstream, so they need to raise the prices so the riff-raff can’t buy it.
    It’s a status symbol for fools, nothing more.

  2. Mark Wadsworth Avatar
    Mark Wadsworth

    What Anitcitizenone says.
    Also, if you use pesticides you can grow more veg for the same amount of inputs (fuel etc) so using pesticides must reduce CO2 emmissions.
    I wish these chaps would make up their minds what they are actually complaining about.
    When I was a kid there was this vision of GM foods that would be resistent to pests, so we’d need less pesticides, well, somebody went to the trouble of actually inventing them and yet still they whine.

  3. “For example, New Zealand lamb, even with the shipping, produces less CO2 than home grown.”
    Tim, I’m curious. On what evidence do you base this assertion?
    Tim adds: I think the report came from Defra. There certainly has been such a report though. Search the archives here.

  4. JuliaM Avatar
    JuliaM

    “.there was I, thinking that organic veg was all about being free of pesticides …”
    Organic veg appeals to the same type of eco-freak that religiously recycles and campaigns for a return to the dark ages, so this was inevitable. They are simply widening their base.

  5. Kay Tie Avatar
    Kay Tie

    The Soil Ass. is a brand. Like all brands, they have to be maintained. If people are buying organic because they are ecomentalists then this will play. If it is because they believe in the quality of the food, then it won’t. Either way, it will wreck the brand or will enhance it.
    Me, I don’t give a tinker’s cuss for the Soil Ass. and it’s politicking. No brand value as far as I’m concerned.

  6. Chris Harrison Avatar
    Chris Harrison

    The Soil Association, an organisation that represents British organic farmers, are advocating a policy that would restrict the organic label to British organic farmers. Nothing to do with the environment, me thinks, but quite a lot to do with protectionism.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Tim Worstall

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading