Will Hutton on Private Equity

I know I’ve mentioned this before but it does seem to be something of a media trope at the moment, the evils of private equity, so worth banging away at the teensiette little bit of hypocrisy here. Will Hutton again:

It is time to come to the defence of the public limited company, one of
the great Enlightenment gifts to western civilisation. Increasingly
capital, in the quest for higher returns to make vast personal
fortunes, is going private to escape the demands of public
accountability on stock markets. If uninterrupted, the long-term
adverse consequences of this privatisation of capital for our economy,
society and democracy will be profound.

OK, so, there’s something special about public companies that make it all work better. Interesting that this view should be propagated in The Guardian, which is owned by the Scott Trust, and thus immune from those public company pressures, is it not? In fact, the very justification for that trust, of which Our Willy is a trustee, is to insulate the Guardian from the pressures of the public markets.

Do as I say, eh, not do as I do?

7 responses

  1. Hypocrisy from someone of the left?
    Surely some mistake.

  2. Katherine Avatar
    Katherine

    Hypocrisy from a human being?
    Surely some mistake.

  3. What does Will H have that, in spite of his bizarre and often contradictory views on the world, he continues to have highb profile jobs.
    Is he loaded so works for free?
    This has puzzled me since his v poor ‘The State We’re In’, so any suggestions welcome.

  4. Tim,
    ‘Do as I say, eh, not do as I do?’
    I don’t get the point.
    The logical conclusion of what I assume your point to be is that a message is only valid if the medium in which it appears is open to the same pressures as that which the message criticises.
    Which is, of course, guff.

  5. Look at the Manic Street Preachers. They always admitted that they were willing prostitutes to Sony in order to get their message out to the masses. You might not like it, but many people believe that short term expediency to bring about revolutionary change is worthwhile and not in the least hypocritical.

  6. Mark Wadsworth Avatar
    Mark Wadsworth

    This month’s whipping boys seem to be City traders, private equity funds and something called “tax deductibility of interest expenses”.
    God it’s all so predictable.

  7. pbr stree Avatar
    pbr stree

    The idiot doesn’t know the difference between the joint stock company and the public limited company.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Tim Worstall

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading