Mindblowing

Polly Toynbee in the comments thread to her piece this morning:

The scare was that Japan would conquer the world. Then the Asian
Tigers, Korea, Malaysia etc. What stopped them? Their inflexible social
structures and their lack of good governance. What Europe has is
rock-solid uncorrupt governance with totally reliable legal systems and
therefore a solid guarantee of all property rights for investors. India
has the most severe infrastructure problems that will slow its growth,
with governments unable to invest enough. China has profound problems
too. Democracy is the only guarantor for business.

Eh? Japan and the Tigers: the scare was there all right but their failure to conquer all was and is nothing to do with inflexible social structures and  lackof good governance. It’s to do with hte fact that the scare was bollocks.

Making things that we wish to purchase is not a reasonable interpretation of the word "conquer" which is why said scare was bollocks in the first place.

And what’s this downer on Japan anyway? I thought Poll was an egalitarian…..and Japan is even more so than Sweden.

Err, we have rock solid uncorrupt governance? L’Escroc? Cash for Honours? Notwork Rail? Swan Hunter? Italy? The EU budget?

Finally, no, democracy is not a guarantor for business. The Rule of Law is, not the same thing at all.

4 responses

  1. Johnathan Pearce Avatar
    Johnathan Pearce

    Has Polly ever heard of Italy?

  2. I think she probably thinks that democracy is the only reliable guarantor of the rule of law, which isn’t totally mad.
    Tim adds: Fair enough, but worth actually saying that. Iraq has lots of democracy but it isn’t, even to one like me thinking about doing business there, a great place to do business: no rule of law, see?

  3. not so sure the EU budget is ‘corruptly’ governed – least ways, not at the brussels end. Grossly inefficient it is though, I grant you that.

  4. Nick (South Africa) Avatar
    Nick (South Africa)

    Polly is an anachronistic socialist…big state, anti free enterprise, punitive taxation….the usual tosh; she’s an economic ‘flat earther’.
    She is to economics what creationists are to biology.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Tim Worstall

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading