Mary Riddell on Transport

Hmmm, this sparked me to go and have a look at something:

The government, meanwhile, cushions airlines with the tax-free fuel and
zero Vat-rating that hand the industry a £9bn annual bonus.

As far as I’m aware, it’s international flights only that don’t pay duty on aviation fuel. So there’s no (or a smaller, at least, as Avgas does not pay the same rate as petrol for road use) subsidy for intra-UK flights:

If I want to go to Glasgow from London at midday tomorrow, I could on
Friday have booked a flight from Luton for £39. A train ticket from
Euston would have cost £100.20p.

But, if we are going to call that a subsidy then this is misleading:

Instead, the government last month published plans that will strangle
railways. Meagre annual subsidies of £4.5bn will be cut to £3.2bn by
2009 and the burden shifted from taxpayers to travellers through higher
fares.

For, as this seems to confirm, trains run on red diesel. 7 p a litre instead of 48 or 54 ( low sulphur or regular). The Virgin fleet alone uses 90m litres (or so it is said…the number does look low to me) so that’s a further £45 million or so a year subsidy to them from the Exchequer.

Or, of course, we can take the attitude that differential taxation rates are not a subsidy: in which case please shut up about Avgas.

But much the most interesting thing to me (and happy to be corrected if I’ve misunderstood this) is that at 25 p a litre or so for Avgas for domestic flights, as against 7 p for red diesel, trains are subsidised, not flights.

6 responses

  1. Kay Tie Avatar
    Kay Tie

    “we can take the attitude that differential taxation rates are not a subsidy”
    Being mugged a bit less often is not the same thing as the mugger handing you cash with a cheery wave.

  2. old possum Avatar
    old possum

    Geek point, but AVGAS is the fuel that aviation piston engines use; in the UK on a commercial domestic flight you’d only come across it if you were flying around the Scottish Islands or to Alderney in a puddle jumper.
    Duty rates on AVGAS are indeed far higher than on AVTUR (JET A-1), which the airliners use.

  3. A worthy geek point though. AVTUR within the UK is duty free (which surprised me) but is liable to VAT.
    Weakens my case above, although I think I can still claim that rail is subsidized more than people think, more than cars…

  4. There are substantial taxes on the price of an airline ticket. Maybe not in the most common forms, such as fuel duty or VAT, but in other forms such as APD. Taxation is high enough and the airlines run themselves viably. The train companies on the other hand get direct handouts from the State. Without state subsidy, they would go bust.
    I think it’s clear which one is paying its way and which one isn’t.

  5. Andrew Duffin Avatar
    Andrew Duffin

    Huh? Where can you buy red diesel for 7p a litre?
    I use red diesel in my boat (quite legally, before anyone starts), and even for large quantities the price is more like 30p a litre.
    Accepted that Virgin trains can buy the stuff by the hundred tons, but even so 7p seems absurd.
    (btw it IS that cheap in Libya, but then they make the stuff. Oh wait, so do we…)
    Tim adds: Err, 7 p is the tax rate….you do also have to pay for the oil, the refinery, the distribution….

  6. “The train companies on the other hand get direct handouts from the State. Without state subsidy, they would go bust.”
    Try having a look at South West Trains or First Great Western’s subsidy/payment profile: subsidy it ain’t…

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Tim Worstall

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading