Reinventing the Wheel

Glorious, absolutely glorious!

Voters will be given powers to decide how ten of millions of pounds
should be spent in their neighbourhood under radical plans being
unveiled today.

In a potentially dramatic extension of direct
democracy, councils will have to hold ballots before deciding where
money should be targeted. It would mean that, for the first time,
people could direct cash to areas that concern them most, such as
parks, curbing antisocial behaviour, targeting drug trouble spots or
cleaning up litter.

Aren’t you just hugging yourself with joy at the idea that people will get to decide how to spend their own money?

Only one small problem. We’ve already got a system to do this, called parish councils. Why not just pass the money to them and let them get on with it?

Or does that not meet the need to have the people as supplicants?

5 responses

  1. H L Mencken wasn’t it?
    “Democracy survives until the people realise that they vote themselves the keys to the Treasury…”

  2. We have an even better mechanism – its called spending our own money from our own pockets.
    Saves the government the hassle of collecting it too.

  3. Aside from agreeing with Tristan, I also agree with Parish Councils. They are directly responsible and are NOT paid a salary, unlike many London “councillors”.

  4. “We’ve already got a system to do this, called parish councils. Why not just pass the money to them and let them get on with it?”
    (a) It doesn’t say they’re not going to use parish councils *where they exist*, which is quite important because
    (b) In many places, including *all of London*, they don’t exist. Or didn’t you know that?

  5. Up to a point Lord Jim!
    The last “initiative” trotted out by this government was to allow places to vote to reparish cities, including London. As part of their “double devolution” idea.
    This is just another platitude trotted out by this government in the absense of a real commitment to localism.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Tim Worstall

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading