A Correction on Recycling

Apologies, a slight mistake on my part re this post.

According to the Waste & Resources Action Programme (Wrap),
recycling currently saves between 10-15m tonnes of greenhouse gases a
year compared to other waste management options.

I, very foolishly, read that as the future plans for more recycling will produce such savings. Of course, it says no such thing, rather, that the current amount of recycling does so. Which, when you look at the report it comes from, makes great sense.

For they are including in this the energy (and thus the CO2 savings) of the recycling of aluminium and steel, amongst other things. Those two even I would agree are worth recycling, not least because you make a profit by doing so, a clear indication that it’s an economically sensible thing to do.

It’s also worth noting (I’ve only skimmed the report) that there are indeed methods of recycling identified which increase CO2 emissions, like glass into aggregate.

I’m perfectly happy with the idea that some forms of recycling reduce emissions, do indeed save resources, just as long as people will agree that there are also types which do not….and that the task is to work out which is which, then do the sensible ones and not do the stupid ones.

3 responses

  1. Mark Wadsworth Avatar
    Mark Wadsworth

    Steel is an interesting one. When I used to take my bin liners of empty Foster’s cans round to Al-Can (£2 a bag if you were lucky) I was told that steel tins were of absolutely no interest to them and went straight on the tip. Have steel prices risen significantly over the past couplel of years? Or does this just relate to big lumps of steel like ships and cars?
    As to glass, recycling doesn’t seem to make sense (economically – even tho’ it used to do) but it will neither burn nor rot. So how about crush it down a bit and chuck it in the North Sea?. It wil arrive back on our beaches in the form of nice shiny sand a few years later. Just a thought.
    Tim adds: Steel in aluminium is a “poison”. So they really don’t like having it there. However, get enough steel cans together and it’s worth some $200, $250 a tonne these days. Less than a quarter what the Al is (actually, much less than that, not been following Al scrap prices.)

  2. Mark Wadsworth Avatar
    Mark Wadsworth

    Scrap steel prices appear to be one-eighth of scrap aluminium.

  3. …and how to disseminate that information once the decision has been made.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Tim Worstall

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading