Doubleplusungood

So, to set up the scene, bloke with HIV and Hep C knowingly and recklessly infected his lover. Get jailed for 9 years. Good. Then comes the HIV charity:

Aids charities criticised the prosecution and the nine-year sentence given to Mola. Debo-rah Jack, chief executive of the National Aids Trust, said: “The National Aids Trust does not condone Giovanni Mola’s actions in recklessly transmitting HIV to Miss X and strongly advises all people living with HIV to protect sexual partners from infection. However, it is important to understand that prosecuting people for reckless transmission of HIV is actually undermining efforts to stop the spread of HIV.

“Stigma and discrimination around HIV is increasing as people living with HIV are cast as criminals, making it even more difficult for them to tell other people. We are particularly concerned at the severity of the sentence. Sending Giovanni Mola to prison is not the way to deal with the HIV epidemic in Scotland and is likely to only make it worse.”

Hunh? Punishing those who infect others, casting a criminal as a criminal, will not reduce infections?

4 responses

  1. “people living with HIV are cast as criminals”
    NO THEY ARE NOT. People living with HIV who recklessly, criminally and deliberately infect others with HIV are cast are criminals.
    Not the same thing at all.
    Let’s try a different example:
    Some people use cars deliberately to mow down small children.
    Such people are jailed.
    Jailing people who deliberately use cars to mow down small children stigmatises anyone and everyone who uses a car ever and may hinder efforts to cut the number of people who use cars to mow down small children.
    Um. Right. I see.

  2. Well, at least he’ll get left alone in the showers in Saughton.

  3. dearieme Avatar
    dearieme

    We urgently need a Charity devoted to abolishing the politics-ridden Charities.

  4. JuliaM Avatar
    JuliaM

    “Debo-rah Jack, chief executive of the National Aids Trust..”
    Is the hyphen a typo by the Times..? Or is she just a typical charity-heading pretentious bitch?

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Tim Worstall

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading