Tony Blair and the Union

Well, of course a Scot running the UK would not be in favour of Scottish independence.

Montreal was once the financial capital of Canada. But even though
    the people of Quebec have turned their back on independence, the
    uncertainty of the future was enough to see it lose its position to
    Toronto. Scotland’s prospering financial sector, for example,
    could suffer the same fate when future investment decisions are made.

Possibly. It might also thrive, as those of Luxembourg, Liechtenstein, the Caymans, Jersey etc. have done. Depends what the tax rates are really, doesn’t it?

Our age is being shaped by the twin forces of globalisation and
    interdependence. In such an era, our Union is not a relic of a
    bygone age, but a quintessentially modern expression of how we find
    common bridges between diverse peoples and hold shared values while
    retaining distinctive identities. What a dismal message it would
    send to the rest of the world that we, on these small islands,
    cannot live together in a political, social and economic union.

The logic of that is that we can only deal with the consequences of globalisation and interdependence by being part of a political, social and economic union. So roll on the EU and one world government then.

Or, to be more realistic, we could say that globalisation and interdependence mean that we actually need less governance, more power devolved to the smaller political units. Even, as we no longer need regulation makers at the higher levels, abolishing those larger political units altogether.

2 responses

  1. “It might also thrive, as those of Luxembourg, Liechtenstein, the Caymans, Jersey etc. have done.”
    It wouldn’t. And it doesn’t depend solely on the tax rates, but also on culture and location.
    “In such an era, our Union is not a relic of a bygone age, but a quintessentially modern expression of how we find common bridges between diverse peoples and hold shared values while retaining distinctive identities. What a dismal message it would send to the rest of the world that we, on these small islands, cannot live together in a political, social and economic union.”
    You should have thought of that before you kicked off the devolution madness.
    Come to think of it, compared to the cost of the Olympics, at £450m the Scottish Parliament looks now looks like a bargain.
    Mind you, the Conservatives should also have thought of that before they destroyed the Union’s very delicate economic balance; a balance based on true Ricardian comparative advantage, the resources and labour of the north working in perfect harmony with the capital of the south to make everyone better off.
    No, we got Hayek instead. The unpalatable reality that many English Brits seem to fail to understand that for a number of us up here ‘The Road to Serfdom’ was not a warning, but an invitation.

  2. The current state of the Union is the short term future of the EU, only worse. Imagine a hundred IRA’s spread across Europe, all demanding independence from the evil EU Empire?
    Only an idiot would ignore it and press ahead. I suppose some turkes do vote for Christmas.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Tim Worstall

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading