Bye Bye Light Bulbs!

I should, for professional reasons, probably welcome this. The EU is to ban incandescent light bulbs. Now I think that metal halide bulbs will still be OK (which we supply materials for) and if so, I expect that the market for them will increase. As the compact flourescents cannot be used on dimmer switches, and also because metal halide bulbs are the only way to get a richer spectrum, I would assume so.

However, there’s a little thing at the end here which makes me wonder whether it is a good idea or not:

There is also an environmental cost to be set against
the energy savings. CFLs contain mercury so extra waste disposal rules
may be required.

Householders will also have to
change their habits in other ways. They will no longer be able to throw
old bulbs out in the rubbish.

Those extra environmental rules have already been proposed. Under the mercury regulations, there should be an entirely separate recycling system, just for mercury containing light bulbs. Given the energy costs of such a thing, I do wonder whether quite as many emissions will be saved as is mooted?

Anyone know?

4 responses

  1. This will be a popular move. Perhaps in twenty years time historians will look back and see this as the tipping point for the full-scale revolt that followed.
    But, more likely, something else we simply moan about and then concede to the unelected soft fascists.

  2. I use energy savers whereever I can, but I also have some wall based timer and dimmer switches which are incompatible with them.
    The trouble is that the energy savers are inductive loads, which isn’t helpful to much electronics!
    Ideally, I’d like there to be some non-inductive replacement which is compatible with the existing fittings for tungsten bulbs. If that doesn’t happen, there’ll be a lot of people being confused at why their dimmer lights no longer work!

  3. Tim,
    I would be very interested to know whether or not any of the so-called ‘heads of government’ respeonsible for this lunacy either hold or benefit from shares in ‘green’ lightbulb manufacturers.
    Tim adds: Wouldn’t have thought so, or rather, that it wouldn’t be important. The flourescents and the incandescents tend to be made by the same companies. GE, Phillips etc.

  4. Bill Whittaker Avatar
    Bill Whittaker

    There is a rather detailed article on this at this electronics website. http://sound.westhost.com/articles/incandescent.htm
    The subject is more complicated than you might think. Basically the author thinks an outright ban will cause lots of pain for little net gain.
    Bill

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Tim Worstall

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading