The Soil Association: a Trade Union

I’ve consistently described the Soil Association as a trade union for organic farmers. Some obviously disagree, but when it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck.

We don’t dispute that the organic sector faces unhelpful moves from
some supermarkets – pushing sales by offering customers organic food as
"cheaply" as possible, and potentially forcing organic farmers on to
the same treadmill as their non-organic counterparts. Our food culture
needs changing so that "cheap" generally means "nasty", and definitely
inferior, as with any other product. Good quality organic food is
within everyone’s price range if people eat a diet based on
unprocessed, seasonal and local food with less (but better-quality)
meat.

That is, without a doubt, a trade union leader making the case that we’d all better pay more for his members output, that for some moral reason his people are more worthy of your money than their competitors outside his union. Even, as he says, that you should limit your consumption and the variety of it so as to give his members higher incomes.

Change a few words and it could be the UAW telling people they should buy American cars.

The Soil Association is a trade union and we should regard it as such.

2 responses

  1. Organic food? Yech! I avoid whenever I can. I don’t see why I should pay extra for food grown in unsanitary condition and using far more land than it should need.

  2. stephen c Avatar
    stephen c

    I did a recent price comparison at my local Waitrose supermarket. Average 30 – 40% higher price for a wide range of vegetables (as much as 90% higher for some items).
    My middle class neighbours can continue to be ripped off as far as I’m concerned. These products do not taste better, are not better for you, do not do anything better for the environment and if organic farming was more widely applied would be a recipe for more poverty.
    Not as bad as organics is all this fair trade branding – at best harmless, at worst a diversion from promoting poverty-reducing free trade. Most likely a device for supermarkets to better identify that part of their customer base willing to part with more consumer surplus than poorer or more canny buyers.

Leave a Reply to JoshCancel reply

Discover more from Tim Worstall

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading