Complimentary Health Care and Alternative Medicine.

Peter Hain in The Independent writes about how happy he is that the NHS now offers complimentary and alternative health care, alongside conventional medicine. We get an endearing look at why the NHS does not, in fact, work. Rather than hiring a few people to stick needles into unexpected places, or perhaps even someone to teach nurses to wash their hands, something that would do a great deal for the health of the nation, this is what he actually applauds:

I am pleased that the Welsh Assembly Government is looking into opportunities to support complementary therapies within the NHS in Wales. Officials have been liaising with the Department of Health and the Prince’s Foundation about these issues and at this stage it has agreed to promote a guide for patients on complementary health care developed by the foundation across Wales.

Bureaucrats get to chat to each other over tea and biscuits while clocking up their inflation proof final salary pensions. Un huh, that’s great Peter, really healing the sick and helping the lame to walk that is. Rather a sad come down in mental capacity for a man who in his younger days had a sure, if perverse, moral certainty in his campaigning against Apartheid. We also see this:

One in five Britons, myself included, now uses complementary health care;

There is, in fact, no such thing as complimentary health care. There is that which works, as proven in double blind tests. This is known as “medical care”. There is that which does not work and depends upon the gullibility of both the provider and the patient. This is known as “not medicine” or mumbo jumbo. That there might be things in the second class which do indeed work, I am willing to believe. Let’s test them in the proper manner and then they will be “medicine”. Otherwise that one in five figure is just proof, once again, that one in five Britons, including the Secretary of State for Wales, are idiots.

3 responses

  1. Daniel Birch Avatar
    Daniel Birch

    Hi Tim,
    I read your blog on a daily basis and agree with your foresight, knowledge and understanding to treat all things with caution and suspicion, especailly politically motivated issues. With regrads to complimentary medicine and alternative therapies I wonder why you tow the line with our Ministry of Health/ British Medical Council (spelt GSK, ASTRA.) Some forms of “alternative” medicine do work and have been proved to work. Take for example homeopathy on animals – they dont know the difference between placebo or double blind tests, but tests have proven that this form of medicine works. Your thought process as highlighted in this blog is non conventional – why should it so conventional with regards to medicine?
    Tim adds: My take on complimentary and alternative medicine is simple. The distinction between those and “conventional” medicine does not exist. If homeopathy does indeed work (and no, there has not yet been a double blind trial that shows that it does) then I’m all for its use. Just as I am for the use of aspirin to reduce heart attacks, the use of antibiotics to treat stomach ulcers now that we know they are bacterially caused, yes, I’ll support reflexology, acupuncture, chiropractic and howling at the moon if they are shown to actually cure disease. Those things that cure disease are “medicine”. Those things that do not are not, and the use of conventional, complementary or alternative as modifiers are redundant.

  2. Andrew Duffin Avatar
    Andrew Duffin

    Can you guys please decide whether you’re talking about complementary medicine or complimentary medicine?
    It’s kind of hard to follow the argument when you keep chopping and changing.
    Tim adds: you’re right of course. Should be complementary not polite right?

  3. Andrew Duffin Avatar
    Andrew Duffin

    And now that I’ve got that off my chest, Daniel it seems you’re saying the exact same thing that Tim said.
    Either it works, whatever it is, in which case it’s medicine, or it doesn’t, in which case it’s not.
    Isn’t that the point?

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Tim Worstall

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading